Homemade Mayonnaise {recipe}

Simple to make with just a few ingredients, homemade mayonnaise is a healthy alternative to store-bought. The best part is, you can vary the taste to your own preferences.

homemade mayonnaise

5.0 from 1 reviews
Homemade Mayonnaise
  • 3 egg yolks
  • (from pastured chickens - it's important to source clean, quality eggs for this as they remain raw)
  • ¼ cup light olive oil
  • ¼ cup sunflower oil
  • ½ teaspoon lemon juice or apple cider vinegar
  • salt to taste
  • optional- whey
  1. Let your eggs come to room temperature or let them sit in a bowl of warm water for a few minutes before starting. (I've found that this helps my mayo succeed every time, though skipping this step will be fine as long as you follow step 2.)
  2. Separate the whites from the yolks. (you can save the whites for something else) and blend the yolks for one to two minutes. I use my blender on the lowest speed though some people use an immersion/stick blender with good success.
  3. Add the lemon juice or ACV to the eggs if you like a mayo with just a touch of zing.
  4. Pour both or your oils together in a measuring cup with a spout and begin slowly pouring it into the blended egg yolks, while the blender is still running. You'll want a very thin stream, especially as you first get started, but can slowly start pouring just a bit faster as it begins to emulsify. (it normally takes me just less than a minute to pour all of the oil in)
  5. Once the oil is completely in the egg yolk mixture and emulsified, pour/scoop it into a bowl and add salt to taste.
If it doesn't work (emulsify) the first time, pour it out into the measuring cup, start with a few new egg yolks and instead of pouring in fresh oil, use your previous attempt. It will be more yellow from the yolks, but the flavor will be about the same.
Some people also like just a touch of sugar in it as well, which can also help wean family off store-bought mayo.
The addition of mustard is a common one, but I hate (like really don't like) mustard. Every once in awhile I'll add a bit of Dijon mustard to the mix if I'm using it for deviled eggs or potato salad, but I normally leave it out.
Adding about ½ tablespoon of whey to the mixture will lacto-ferment the mayo. Just add it to the egg yolks as you begin blending and let it sit out for a few hours before refrigerating.
Source your eggs from a well trusted farmer as these egg yolks will remain raw. I would have a hard time using store-bought eggs for this, but I trust the safety of my eggs.
You can also use this basic mayo as a base for dips, adding in your favorite seasonings. (adding taco seasoning would be great to use for Mexican dishes, etc)

Donielle Baker

Donielle Baker

owner and editor of Natural Fertility and Wellness at Natural Fertility and Wellness
Donielle believes women can learn how to heal their bodies & balance their hormones through natural methods. An advocate for natural health, she has a passion for nourishing/real food nutrition and natural living. Her personal background includes both infertility and miscarriage and she started Natural Fertility and Wellness in 2008 in order to share all of the information she found helpful in her journey to heal from PCOS and overcome infertility.
Donielle Baker
Donielle Baker
Donielle Baker
Many of the links on this site are affiliate links, which mean that the owner of the site may earn a small commission from your purchase through the company. We will not recommend a company that we do not purchase from ourselves and we thank you for your support. No contributor or author on this site is a medical doctor and the statements made here have not been approved by the Food and Drug Administration. These statements are not intended to diagnose, treat or cure or prevent any disease. This notice is required by the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. Read our privacy policy and full disclosure here.


    • donielle says

      @Mary @ Homemade Dutch Apple Pie, Nope! Same process, just different ingredients! :-) (I loathe mustard…..blech!) And you know, I’ve tried it once or twice with my stick blender and it just didn’t work well at all. I wish it did, because it can get slightly messing getting it out of the blender!

      Also? I love how everyone’s mayo recipe is different. It really goes to show how we all begin making our food to our families preferences! Which I think is fantastic – instead of accepting the flavor of processed foods.

  1. Danielle says

    I have great, super-easy replacement for mayo! It doesn’t really taste like mayo, but it is natural, delicious and SUPER-EASY! (I’ve spread the word to all my heath-conscious friends – so I figured I’d share here, too!)

    The only ingredients are avocado and greek yogurt (full fat, please!).
    Depending on how much you will use at a time, use half an avocado and 1 tablespoon of greek yogurt. Mash up the avocado first, to a creamy consistency, then add the yogurt. It has the consistency of mayo, but so much better!!!

  2. Beth says

    This looks wonderful and easy! I have been so afraid to try, I guess I just needed someone to hold my hand through the process. I will definitely be trying this soon!

  3. Josee says

    I’ll offer a little constructive criticism….”The olive oil that you see on the supermarket self advertised as “light” or as “Extra Light” olive oil contains the exact same number of calories as regular olive oil and is a mixture of refined olive oils that are derived from the lowest quality olive oils available through chemical processing. These oils are so bad that cannot be consumed by humans without refining. These types of oils also contain significant portions of other lower cost oils such as Canola and Hazelnut oil which have virtually no flavor of their own. They may contain some extra virgin or virgin olive oil (1% maximum). The term “light” or “extra light” refers to the lighter color, fragrance, and flavor obtained by an extremely fine filtration and refining process and not to the amount of calories that the oil contains. We recommend to our customers to stay away from these products because they are industrial products of very low quality.”

    Extra virgin olive oil would be far superior in terms of health. If your like me though, it does take some getting used to the robust flavor. I was determined to stick with it and now and I really love it!!

    • donielle says

      @Josee, Ah yes, I foget about that pesky stuff from the supermarkets. :-) I’ve been buying mine through co-ops and directly from the source for so long that I forget not every ‘light’ oil is as good as what I use.
      Thanks for the reminder!

  4. helene says

    just an aside, beware note:
    coconut oil in mayo is GROSS. i tried it half and half and we cud barely tolerate it on tunafish or chicken salad. i threw out half of the recipe :( next i did 1/4 to 3/4 and still BLECH. it sits lonely and unused anymore in my fridge… i knew i didnt want EVO in it already, very strong. sigh…im going back to canola oil with something healthful for the other half and at least im not eating soybean oil like the storebought is.

    • says

      I agree with you, I’m not a fan of coconut oil in my mayo! Plus, it hardens a bit too much when refrigerated.

      I’d recommend sunflower oil, it’s what I use and has a super light flavor like canola does. I also get a good quality light olive oil that I like from a local co-op group.

  5. Stephanie says

    I know this isn’t really conventional but it worked for what I needed. I used half expeller pressed coconut oil (no coconut flavor) and half melted but cooled butter. We ate it right away so I’m not sure how it would be refridgerated. It was all we had in the house. Next time, I’ll probably try the sunflower oil and butter.